spirv-fuzz: Wrap early terminators before merging returns (#3925)

Incorporates some other fixes for issues that were brought to light by
adding this functionality.

Fixes #3717.
Fixes #3924.
This commit is contained in:
Alastair Donaldson 2020-10-16 19:29:39 +01:00 committed by GitHub
parent fd3948e161
commit bf1a11dab7
No known key found for this signature in database
GPG Key ID: 4AEE18F83AFDEB23
15 changed files with 462 additions and 145 deletions

View File

@ -581,10 +581,18 @@ void DataSynonymAndIdEquationFacts::ComputeClosureOfFacts(
synonymous_.IsEquivalent(dd1_prefix, dd2_prefix)) { synonymous_.IsEquivalent(dd1_prefix, dd2_prefix)) {
continue; continue;
} }
opt::Instruction* dd1_object =
ir_context_->get_def_use_mgr()->GetDef(dd1->object());
opt::Instruction* dd2_object =
ir_context_->get_def_use_mgr()->GetDef(dd2->object());
if (dd1_object == nullptr || dd2_object == nullptr) {
// The objects are not both available in the module, so we cannot
// investigate the types of the associated data descriptors; we need
// to move on.
continue;
}
// Get the type of obj_1 // Get the type of obj_1
auto dd1_root_type_id = auto dd1_root_type_id = dd1_object->type_id();
ir_context_->get_def_use_mgr()->GetDef(dd1->object())->type_id();
// Use this type, together with a_1, ..., a_m, to get the type of // Use this type, together with a_1, ..., a_m, to get the type of
// obj_1[a_1, ..., a_m]. // obj_1[a_1, ..., a_m].
auto dd1_prefix_type = fuzzerutil::WalkCompositeTypeIndices( auto dd1_prefix_type = fuzzerutil::WalkCompositeTypeIndices(
@ -592,8 +600,7 @@ void DataSynonymAndIdEquationFacts::ComputeClosureOfFacts(
// Similarly, get the type of obj_2 and use it to get the type of // Similarly, get the type of obj_2 and use it to get the type of
// obj_2[b_1, ..., b_n]. // obj_2[b_1, ..., b_n].
auto dd2_root_type_id = auto dd2_root_type_id = dd2_object->type_id();
ir_context_->get_def_use_mgr()->GetDef(dd2->object())->type_id();
auto dd2_prefix_type = fuzzerutil::WalkCompositeTypeIndices( auto dd2_prefix_type = fuzzerutil::WalkCompositeTypeIndices(
ir_context_, dd2_root_type_id, dd2_prefix.index()); ir_context_, dd2_root_type_id, dd2_prefix.index());

View File

@ -100,6 +100,72 @@ std::vector<opt::Instruction*> FuzzerPass::FindAvailableInstructions(
return result; return result;
} }
void FuzzerPass::ForEachInstructionWithInstructionDescriptor(
opt::Function* function,
std::function<
void(opt::BasicBlock* block, opt::BasicBlock::iterator inst_it,
const protobufs::InstructionDescriptor& instruction_descriptor)>
action) {
// Consider only reachable blocks. We do this in a separate loop to avoid
// recomputing the dominator analysis every time |action| changes the
// module.
std::vector<opt::BasicBlock*> reachable_blocks;
const auto* dominator_analysis =
GetIRContext()->GetDominatorAnalysis(function);
for (auto& block : *function) {
if (dominator_analysis->IsReachable(&block)) {
reachable_blocks.push_back(&block);
}
}
for (auto* block : reachable_blocks) {
// We now consider every instruction in the block, randomly deciding
// whether to apply a transformation before it.
// In order for transformations to insert new instructions, they need to
// be able to identify the instruction to insert before. We describe an
// instruction via its opcode, 'opc', a base instruction 'base' that has a
// result id, and the number of instructions with opcode 'opc' that we
// should skip when searching from 'base' for the desired instruction.
// (An instruction that has a result id is represented by its own opcode,
// itself as 'base', and a skip-count of 0.)
std::vector<std::tuple<uint32_t, SpvOp, uint32_t>> base_opcode_skip_triples;
// The initial base instruction is the block label.
uint32_t base = block->id();
// Counts the number of times we have seen each opcode since we reset the
// base instruction.
std::map<SpvOp, uint32_t> skip_count;
// Consider every instruction in the block. The label is excluded: it is
// only necessary to consider it as a base in case the first instruction
// in the block does not have a result id.
for (auto inst_it = block->begin(); inst_it != block->end(); ++inst_it) {
if (inst_it->HasResultId()) {
// In the case that the instruction has a result id, we use the
// instruction as its own base, and clear the skip counts we have
// collected.
base = inst_it->result_id();
skip_count.clear();
}
const SpvOp opcode = inst_it->opcode();
// Invoke the provided function, which might apply a transformation.
action(block, inst_it,
MakeInstructionDescriptor(
base, opcode,
skip_count.count(opcode) ? skip_count.at(opcode) : 0));
if (!inst_it->HasResultId()) {
skip_count[opcode] =
skip_count.count(opcode) ? skip_count.at(opcode) + 1 : 1;
}
}
}
}
void FuzzerPass::ForEachInstructionWithInstructionDescriptor( void FuzzerPass::ForEachInstructionWithInstructionDescriptor(
std::function< std::function<
void(opt::Function* function, opt::BasicBlock* block, void(opt::Function* function, opt::BasicBlock* block,
@ -108,65 +174,13 @@ void FuzzerPass::ForEachInstructionWithInstructionDescriptor(
action) { action) {
// Consider every block in every function. // Consider every block in every function.
for (auto& function : *GetIRContext()->module()) { for (auto& function : *GetIRContext()->module()) {
// Consider only reachable blocks. We do this in a separate loop to avoid ForEachInstructionWithInstructionDescriptor(
// recomputing the dominator analysis every time |action| changes the &function,
// module. [&action, &function](
std::vector<opt::BasicBlock*> reachable_blocks; opt::BasicBlock* block, opt::BasicBlock::iterator inst_it,
const protobufs::InstructionDescriptor& instruction_descriptor) {
const auto* dominator_analysis = action(&function, block, inst_it, instruction_descriptor);
GetIRContext()->GetDominatorAnalysis(&function); });
for (auto& block : function) {
if (dominator_analysis->IsReachable(&block)) {
reachable_blocks.push_back(&block);
}
}
for (auto* block : reachable_blocks) {
// We now consider every instruction in the block, randomly deciding
// whether to apply a transformation before it.
// In order for transformations to insert new instructions, they need to
// be able to identify the instruction to insert before. We describe an
// instruction via its opcode, 'opc', a base instruction 'base' that has a
// result id, and the number of instructions with opcode 'opc' that we
// should skip when searching from 'base' for the desired instruction.
// (An instruction that has a result id is represented by its own opcode,
// itself as 'base', and a skip-count of 0.)
std::vector<std::tuple<uint32_t, SpvOp, uint32_t>>
base_opcode_skip_triples;
// The initial base instruction is the block label.
uint32_t base = block->id();
// Counts the number of times we have seen each opcode since we reset the
// base instruction.
std::map<SpvOp, uint32_t> skip_count;
// Consider every instruction in the block. The label is excluded: it is
// only necessary to consider it as a base in case the first instruction
// in the block does not have a result id.
for (auto inst_it = block->begin(); inst_it != block->end(); ++inst_it) {
if (inst_it->HasResultId()) {
// In the case that the instruction has a result id, we use the
// instruction as its own base, and clear the skip counts we have
// collected.
base = inst_it->result_id();
skip_count.clear();
}
const SpvOp opcode = inst_it->opcode();
// Invoke the provided function, which might apply a transformation.
action(&function, block, inst_it,
MakeInstructionDescriptor(
base, opcode,
skip_count.count(opcode) ? skip_count.at(opcode) : 0));
if (!inst_it->HasResultId()) {
skip_count[opcode] =
skip_count.count(opcode) ? skip_count.at(opcode) + 1 : 1;
}
}
}
} }
} }

View File

@ -71,8 +71,8 @@ class FuzzerPass {
instruction_is_relevant) const; instruction_is_relevant) const;
// A helper method that iterates through each instruction in each reachable // A helper method that iterates through each instruction in each reachable
// block, at all times tracking an instruction descriptor that allows the // block of |function|, at all times tracking an instruction descriptor that
// latest instruction to be located even if it has no result id. // allows the latest instruction to be located even if it has no result id.
// //
// The code to manipulate the instruction descriptor is a bit fiddly. The // The code to manipulate the instruction descriptor is a bit fiddly. The
// point of this method is to avoiding having to duplicate it in multiple // point of this method is to avoiding having to duplicate it in multiple
@ -86,6 +86,17 @@ class FuzzerPass {
// In most intended use cases, the job of |action| is to randomly decide // In most intended use cases, the job of |action| is to randomly decide
// whether to try to apply some transformation, and then - if selected - to // whether to try to apply some transformation, and then - if selected - to
// attempt to apply it. // attempt to apply it.
void ForEachInstructionWithInstructionDescriptor(
opt::Function* function,
std::function<
void(opt::BasicBlock* block, opt::BasicBlock::iterator inst_it,
const protobufs::InstructionDescriptor& instruction_descriptor)>
action);
// Applies the above overload of ForEachInstructionWithInstructionDescriptor
// to every function in the module, so that |action| is applied to an
// |instruction_descriptor| for every instruction, |inst_it|, of every |block|
// in every |function|.
void ForEachInstructionWithInstructionDescriptor( void ForEachInstructionWithInstructionDescriptor(
std::function< std::function<
void(opt::Function* function, opt::BasicBlock* block, void(opt::Function* function, opt::BasicBlock* block,
@ -100,7 +111,12 @@ class FuzzerPass {
*GetTransformationContext()) && *GetTransformationContext()) &&
"Transformation should be applicable by construction."); "Transformation should be applicable by construction.");
transformation.Apply(GetIRContext(), GetTransformationContext()); transformation.Apply(GetIRContext(), GetTransformationContext());
*GetTransformations()->add_transformation() = transformation.ToMessage(); protobufs::Transformation transformation_message =
transformation.ToMessage();
assert(transformation_message.transformation_case() !=
protobufs::Transformation::TRANSFORMATION_NOT_SET &&
"Bad transformation.");
*GetTransformations()->add_transformation() = transformation_message;
} }
// A generic helper for applying a transformation only if it is applicable. // A generic helper for applying a transformation only if it is applicable.
@ -111,7 +127,12 @@ class FuzzerPass {
if (transformation.IsApplicable(GetIRContext(), if (transformation.IsApplicable(GetIRContext(),
*GetTransformationContext())) { *GetTransformationContext())) {
transformation.Apply(GetIRContext(), GetTransformationContext()); transformation.Apply(GetIRContext(), GetTransformationContext());
*GetTransformations()->add_transformation() = transformation.ToMessage(); protobufs::Transformation transformation_message =
transformation.ToMessage();
assert(transformation_message.transformation_case() !=
protobufs::Transformation::TRANSFORMATION_NOT_SET &&
"Bad transformation.");
*GetTransformations()->add_transformation() = transformation_message;
return true; return true;
} }
return false; return false;

View File

@ -16,7 +16,9 @@
#include "source/fuzz/fuzzer_util.h" #include "source/fuzz/fuzzer_util.h"
#include "source/fuzz/instruction_descriptor.h" #include "source/fuzz/instruction_descriptor.h"
#include "source/fuzz/transformation_add_early_terminator_wrapper.h"
#include "source/fuzz/transformation_merge_function_returns.h" #include "source/fuzz/transformation_merge_function_returns.h"
#include "source/fuzz/transformation_wrap_early_terminator_in_function.h"
namespace spvtools { namespace spvtools {
namespace fuzz { namespace fuzz {
@ -31,7 +33,15 @@ FuzzerPassMergeFunctionReturns::FuzzerPassMergeFunctionReturns(
FuzzerPassMergeFunctionReturns::~FuzzerPassMergeFunctionReturns() = default; FuzzerPassMergeFunctionReturns::~FuzzerPassMergeFunctionReturns() = default;
void FuzzerPassMergeFunctionReturns::Apply() { void FuzzerPassMergeFunctionReturns::Apply() {
// The pass might add new functions to the module (due to wrapping early
// terminator instructions in function calls), so we record the functions that
// are currently present and then iterate over them.
std::vector<opt::Function*> functions;
for (auto& function : *GetIRContext()->module()) { for (auto& function : *GetIRContext()->module()) {
functions.emplace_back(&function);
}
for (auto* function : functions) {
// Randomly decide whether to consider this function. // Randomly decide whether to consider this function.
if (GetFuzzerContext()->ChoosePercentage( if (GetFuzzerContext()->ChoosePercentage(
GetFuzzerContext()->GetChanceOfMergingFunctionReturns())) { GetFuzzerContext()->GetChanceOfMergingFunctionReturns())) {
@ -39,13 +49,66 @@ void FuzzerPassMergeFunctionReturns::Apply() {
} }
// Only consider functions that have early returns. // Only consider functions that have early returns.
if (!function.HasEarlyReturn()) { if (!function->HasEarlyReturn()) {
continue; continue;
} }
// Wrap early terminators in function calls.
ForEachInstructionWithInstructionDescriptor(
function,
[this, function](
opt::BasicBlock* /*unused*/, opt::BasicBlock::iterator inst_it,
const protobufs::InstructionDescriptor& instruction_descriptor) {
const SpvOp opcode = inst_it->opcode();
switch (opcode) {
case SpvOpKill:
case SpvOpUnreachable:
case SpvOpTerminateInvocation: {
// This is an early termination instruction - we need to wrap it
// so that it becomes a return.
if (TransformationWrapEarlyTerminatorInFunction::
MaybeGetWrapperFunction(GetIRContext(), opcode) ==
nullptr) {
// We don't have a suitable wrapper function, so create one.
ApplyTransformation(TransformationAddEarlyTerminatorWrapper(
GetFuzzerContext()->GetFreshId(),
GetFuzzerContext()->GetFreshId(), opcode));
}
// If the function has non-void return type then we need a
// suitable value to use in an OpReturnValue instruction.
opt::Instruction* function_return_type =
GetIRContext()->get_def_use_mgr()->GetDef(
function->type_id());
uint32_t returned_value_id;
if (function_return_type->opcode() == SpvOpTypeVoid) {
// No value is needed.
returned_value_id = 0;
} else if (fuzzerutil::CanCreateConstant(
GetIRContext(),
function_return_type->result_id())) {
// We favour returning an irrelevant zero.
returned_value_id = FindOrCreateZeroConstant(
function_return_type->result_id(), true);
} else {
// It's not possible to use an irrelevant zero, so we use an
// OpUndef instead.
returned_value_id =
FindOrCreateGlobalUndef(function_return_type->result_id());
}
// Wrap the early termination instruction in a function call.
ApplyTransformation(TransformationWrapEarlyTerminatorInFunction(
GetFuzzerContext()->GetFreshId(), instruction_descriptor,
returned_value_id));
break;
}
default:
break;
}
});
// Get the return blocks. // Get the return blocks.
auto return_blocks = fuzzerutil::GetReachableReturnBlocks( auto return_blocks = fuzzerutil::GetReachableReturnBlocks(
GetIRContext(), function.result_id()); GetIRContext(), function->result_id());
// Only go ahead if there is more than one reachable return block. // Only go ahead if there is more than one reachable return block.
if (return_blocks.size() <= 1) { if (return_blocks.size() <= 1) {
@ -58,12 +121,12 @@ void FuzzerPassMergeFunctionReturns::Apply() {
// Collect the ids available after the entry block of the function. // Collect the ids available after the entry block of the function.
auto ids_available_after_entry_block = auto ids_available_after_entry_block =
GetTypesToIdsAvailableAfterEntryBlock(&function); GetTypesToIdsAvailableAfterEntryBlock(function);
// If the entry block does not branch unconditionally to another block, // If the entry block does not branch unconditionally to another block,
// split it. // split it.
if (function.entry()->terminator()->opcode() != SpvOpBranch) { if (function->entry()->terminator()->opcode() != SpvOpBranch) {
SplitBlockAfterOpPhiOrOpVariable(function.entry()->id()); SplitBlockAfterOpPhiOrOpVariable(function->entry()->id());
} }
// Collect the merge blocks of the function whose corresponding loops // Collect the merge blocks of the function whose corresponding loops
@ -109,7 +172,7 @@ void FuzzerPassMergeFunctionReturns::Apply() {
uint32_t outer_return_id = GetFuzzerContext()->GetFreshId(); uint32_t outer_return_id = GetFuzzerContext()->GetFreshId();
bool function_is_void = bool function_is_void =
GetIRContext()->get_type_mgr()->GetType(function.type_id())->AsVoid(); GetIRContext()->get_type_mgr()->GetType(function->type_id())->AsVoid();
// We only need a return value if the function is not void. // We only need a return value if the function is not void.
uint32_t return_val_id = uint32_t return_val_id =
@ -120,17 +183,17 @@ void FuzzerPassMergeFunctionReturns::Apply() {
uint32_t returnable_val_id = 0; uint32_t returnable_val_id = 0;
if (!function_is_void && !actual_merge_blocks.empty()) { if (!function_is_void && !actual_merge_blocks.empty()) {
// If there is an id of the suitable type, choose one at random. // If there is an id of the suitable type, choose one at random.
if (ids_available_after_entry_block.count(function.type_id())) { if (ids_available_after_entry_block.count(function->type_id())) {
const auto& candidates = const auto& candidates =
ids_available_after_entry_block[function.type_id()]; ids_available_after_entry_block[function->type_id()];
returnable_val_id = returnable_val_id =
candidates[GetFuzzerContext()->RandomIndex(candidates)]; candidates[GetFuzzerContext()->RandomIndex(candidates)];
} else { } else {
// If there is no id, add a global OpUndef. // If there is no id, add a global OpUndef.
uint32_t suitable_id = FindOrCreateGlobalUndef(function.type_id()); uint32_t suitable_id = FindOrCreateGlobalUndef(function->type_id());
// Add the new id to the map of available ids. // Add the new id to the map of available ids.
ids_available_after_entry_block.emplace( ids_available_after_entry_block.emplace(
function.type_id(), std::vector<uint32_t>({suitable_id})); function->type_id(), std::vector<uint32_t>({suitable_id}));
returnable_val_id = suitable_id; returnable_val_id = suitable_id;
} }
} }
@ -142,7 +205,7 @@ void FuzzerPassMergeFunctionReturns::Apply() {
// Apply the transformation if it is applicable (it could be inapplicable if // Apply the transformation if it is applicable (it could be inapplicable if
// adding new predecessors to merge blocks breaks dominance rules). // adding new predecessors to merge blocks breaks dominance rules).
MaybeApplyTransformation(TransformationMergeFunctionReturns( MaybeApplyTransformation(TransformationMergeFunctionReturns(
function.result_id(), outer_header_id, outer_return_id, return_val_id, function->result_id(), outer_header_id, outer_return_id, return_val_id,
returnable_val_id, merge_blocks_info)); returnable_val_id, merge_blocks_info));
} }
} }

View File

@ -21,7 +21,11 @@ namespace spvtools {
namespace fuzz { namespace fuzz {
// A fuzzer pass for changing functions in the module so that they don't have an // A fuzzer pass for changing functions in the module so that they don't have an
// early return. // early return. When handling a function the pass first eliminates early
// terminator instructions, such as OpKill, by wrapping them in functions and
// replacing them with a function call followed by a return. The return
// instructions that arise are then modified so that the function does not have
// early returns.
class FuzzerPassMergeFunctionReturns : public FuzzerPass { class FuzzerPassMergeFunctionReturns : public FuzzerPass {
public: public:
FuzzerPassMergeFunctionReturns( FuzzerPassMergeFunctionReturns(

View File

@ -52,7 +52,6 @@ void FuzzerPassPropagateInstructionsUp::Apply() {
fresh_id = GetFuzzerContext()->GetFreshId(); fresh_id = GetFuzzerContext()->GetFreshId();
} }
} }
ApplyTransformation( ApplyTransformation(
TransformationPropagateInstructionUp(block.id(), fresh_ids)); TransformationPropagateInstructionUp(block.id(), fresh_ids));
} }

View File

@ -555,6 +555,7 @@ message Transformation {
TransformationPropagateInstructionDown propagate_instruction_down = 81; TransformationPropagateInstructionDown propagate_instruction_down = 81;
TransformationReplaceBranchFromDeadBlockWithExit replace_branch_from_dead_block_with_exit = 82; TransformationReplaceBranchFromDeadBlockWithExit replace_branch_from_dead_block_with_exit = 82;
TransformationWrapEarlyTerminatorInFunction wrap_early_terminator_in_function = 83; TransformationWrapEarlyTerminatorInFunction wrap_early_terminator_in_function = 83;
TransformationMergeFunctionReturns merge_function_returns = 84;
// Add additional option using the next available number. // Add additional option using the next available number.
} }
} }

View File

@ -64,6 +64,7 @@
#include "source/fuzz/transformation_load.h" #include "source/fuzz/transformation_load.h"
#include "source/fuzz/transformation_make_vector_operation_dynamic.h" #include "source/fuzz/transformation_make_vector_operation_dynamic.h"
#include "source/fuzz/transformation_merge_blocks.h" #include "source/fuzz/transformation_merge_blocks.h"
#include "source/fuzz/transformation_merge_function_returns.h"
#include "source/fuzz/transformation_move_block_down.h" #include "source/fuzz/transformation_move_block_down.h"
#include "source/fuzz/transformation_move_instruction_down.h" #include "source/fuzz/transformation_move_instruction_down.h"
#include "source/fuzz/transformation_mutate_pointer.h" #include "source/fuzz/transformation_mutate_pointer.h"
@ -245,6 +246,9 @@ std::unique_ptr<Transformation> Transformation::FromMessage(
message.make_vector_operation_dynamic()); message.make_vector_operation_dynamic());
case protobufs::Transformation::TransformationCase::kMergeBlocks: case protobufs::Transformation::TransformationCase::kMergeBlocks:
return MakeUnique<TransformationMergeBlocks>(message.merge_blocks()); return MakeUnique<TransformationMergeBlocks>(message.merge_blocks());
case protobufs::Transformation::TransformationCase::kMergeFunctionReturns:
return MakeUnique<TransformationMergeFunctionReturns>(
message.merge_function_returns());
case protobufs::Transformation::TransformationCase::kMoveBlockDown: case protobufs::Transformation::TransformationCase::kMoveBlockDown:
return MakeUnique<TransformationMoveBlockDown>(message.move_block_down()); return MakeUnique<TransformationMoveBlockDown>(message.move_block_down());
case protobufs::Transformation::TransformationCase::kMoveInstructionDown: case protobufs::Transformation::TransformationCase::kMoveInstructionDown:

View File

@ -189,11 +189,10 @@ void TransformationAddLoopPreheader::Apply(
// Update the OpPhi instruction in the header so that it refers to the // Update the OpPhi instruction in the header so that it refers to the
// back edge block and the preheader as the predecessors, and it uses the // back edge block and the preheader as the predecessors, and it uses the
// newly-defined OpPhi in the preheader for the corresponding value. // newly-defined OpPhi in the preheader for the corresponding value.
phi_inst->SetInOperands( phi_inst->SetInOperands({{SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_ID, {fresh_phi_id}},
{{SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_RESULT_ID, {fresh_phi_id}}, {SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_ID, {preheader->id()}},
{SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_RESULT_ID, {preheader->id()}}, {SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_ID, {back_edge_val}},
{SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_RESULT_ID, {back_edge_val}}, {SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_ID, {back_edge_block_id}}});
{SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_RESULT_ID, {back_edge_block_id}}});
} }
}); });
@ -201,11 +200,11 @@ void TransformationAddLoopPreheader::Apply(
fuzzerutil::UpdateModuleIdBound(ir_context, message_.fresh_id()); fuzzerutil::UpdateModuleIdBound(ir_context, message_.fresh_id());
// Add an unconditional branch from the preheader to the header. // Add an unconditional branch from the preheader to the header.
preheader->AddInstruction(std::unique_ptr<opt::Instruction>( preheader->AddInstruction(
new opt::Instruction(ir_context, SpvOpBranch, 0, 0, std::unique_ptr<opt::Instruction>(new opt::Instruction(
std::initializer_list<opt::Operand>{opt::Operand( ir_context, SpvOpBranch, 0, 0,
spv_operand_type_t::SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_RESULT_ID, std::initializer_list<opt::Operand>{opt::Operand(
{loop_header->id()})}))); spv_operand_type_t::SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_ID, {loop_header->id()})})));
// Insert the preheader in the module. // Insert the preheader in the module.
loop_header->GetParent()->InsertBasicBlockBefore(std::move(preheader), loop_header->GetParent()->InsertBasicBlockBefore(std::move(preheader),

View File

@ -284,7 +284,7 @@ void TransformationMergeFunctionReturns::Apply(
// Replace the return instruction with an unconditional branch. // Replace the return instruction with an unconditional branch.
ret_block->terminator()->SetOpcode(SpvOpBranch); ret_block->terminator()->SetOpcode(SpvOpBranch);
ret_block->terminator()->SetInOperands( ret_block->terminator()->SetInOperands(
{{SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_RESULT_ID, {merge_block_id}}}); {{SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_ID, {merge_block_id}}});
} }
// Get a list of all the relevant merge blocks. // Get a list of all the relevant merge blocks.
@ -345,32 +345,33 @@ void TransformationMergeFunctionReturns::Apply(
auto merge_block = ir_context->get_instr_block(merge_block_id); auto merge_block = ir_context->get_instr_block(merge_block_id);
// Adjust the existing OpPhi instructions. // Adjust the existing OpPhi instructions.
merge_block->ForEachPhiInst([&preds, &returning_preds, &phi_to_id, merge_block->ForEachPhiInst(
&types_to_available_ids]( [&preds, &returning_preds, &phi_to_id,
opt::Instruction* inst) { &types_to_available_ids](opt::Instruction* inst) {
// We need a placeholder value id. If |phi_to_id| contains a mapping // We need a placeholder value id. If |phi_to_id| contains a mapping
// for this instruction, we use the given id, otherwise a suitable id // for this instruction, we use the given id, otherwise a suitable id
// for the instruction's type from |types_to_available_ids|. // for the instruction's type from |types_to_available_ids|.
uint32_t placeholder_val_id = uint32_t placeholder_val_id =
phi_to_id.count(inst->result_id()) phi_to_id.count(inst->result_id())
? phi_to_id[inst->result_id()] ? phi_to_id[inst->result_id()]
: types_to_available_ids[inst->type_id()]; : types_to_available_ids[inst->type_id()];
assert(placeholder_val_id && assert(placeholder_val_id &&
"We should always be able to find a suitable if the " "We should always be able to find a suitable if the "
"transformation is applicable."); "transformation is applicable.");
// Add a pair of operands (placeholder id, new predecessor) for each // Add a pair of operands (placeholder id, new predecessor) for each
// new predecessor of the merge block. // new predecessor of the merge block.
for (const auto& entry : returning_preds) { for (const auto& entry : returning_preds) {
// A returning predecessor may already be a predecessor of the // A returning predecessor may already be a predecessor of the
// block. In that case, we should not add new operands. // block. In that case, we should not add new operands.
// Each entry is in the form (predecessor, {return val, is returning}). // Each entry is in the form (predecessor, {return val, is
if (!preds.count(entry.first)) { // returning}).
inst->AddOperand({SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_RESULT_ID, {placeholder_val_id}}); if (!preds.count(entry.first)) {
inst->AddOperand({SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_RESULT_ID, {entry.first}}); inst->AddOperand({SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_ID, {placeholder_val_id}});
} inst->AddOperand({SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_ID, {entry.first}});
} }
}); }
});
// If the function is not void, add a new OpPhi instructions to collect the // If the function is not void, add a new OpPhi instructions to collect the
// return value from the returning predecessors. // return value from the returning predecessors.
@ -383,9 +384,9 @@ void TransformationMergeFunctionReturns::Apply(
// Each entry is in the form (predecessor, {return value, // Each entry is in the form (predecessor, {return value,
// is returning}). // is returning}).
operand_list.emplace_back( operand_list.emplace_back(
opt::Operand{SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_RESULT_ID, {entry.second.first}}); opt::Operand{SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_ID, {entry.second.first}});
operand_list.emplace_back( operand_list.emplace_back(
opt::Operand{SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_RESULT_ID, {entry.first}}); opt::Operand{SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_ID, {entry.first}});
} }
// Add two operands for each original predecessor from which the function // Add two operands for each original predecessor from which the function
@ -398,9 +399,9 @@ void TransformationMergeFunctionReturns::Apply(
} }
operand_list.emplace_back( operand_list.emplace_back(
opt::Operand{SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_RESULT_ID, {returnable_val_id}}); opt::Operand{SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_ID, {returnable_val_id}});
operand_list.emplace_back( operand_list.emplace_back(
opt::Operand{SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_RESULT_ID, {original_pred}}); opt::Operand{SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_ID, {original_pred}});
} }
// Insert the instruction. // Insert the instruction.
@ -421,9 +422,9 @@ void TransformationMergeFunctionReturns::Apply(
// Each entry is in the form (predecessor, {return value, // Each entry is in the form (predecessor, {return value,
// is returning}). // is returning}).
operand_list.emplace_back( operand_list.emplace_back(
opt::Operand{SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_RESULT_ID, {entry.second.second}}); opt::Operand{SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_ID, {entry.second.second}});
operand_list.emplace_back( operand_list.emplace_back(
opt::Operand{SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_RESULT_ID, {entry.first}}); opt::Operand{SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_ID, {entry.first}});
} }
// Add two operands for each original predecessor from which the function // Add two operands for each original predecessor from which the function
@ -436,9 +437,9 @@ void TransformationMergeFunctionReturns::Apply(
} }
operand_list.emplace_back( operand_list.emplace_back(
opt::Operand{SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_RESULT_ID, {constant_false}}); opt::Operand{SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_ID, {constant_false}});
operand_list.emplace_back( operand_list.emplace_back(
opt::Operand{SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_RESULT_ID, {original_pred}}); opt::Operand{SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_ID, {original_pred}});
} }
// Insert the instruction. // Insert the instruction.
@ -480,9 +481,9 @@ void TransformationMergeFunctionReturns::Apply(
// true, to |original_succ| otherwise. // true, to |original_succ| otherwise.
merge_block->terminator()->SetOpcode(SpvOpBranchConditional); merge_block->terminator()->SetOpcode(SpvOpBranchConditional);
merge_block->terminator()->SetInOperands( merge_block->terminator()->SetInOperands(
{{SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_RESULT_ID, {is_returning_id}}, {{SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_ID, {is_returning_id}},
{SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_RESULT_ID, {enclosing_merge}}, {SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_ID, {enclosing_merge}},
{SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_RESULT_ID, {original_succ}}}); {SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_ID, {original_succ}}});
} }
assert(function->entry()->terminator()->opcode() == SpvOpBranch && assert(function->entry()->terminator()->opcode() == SpvOpBranch &&
@ -503,8 +504,8 @@ void TransformationMergeFunctionReturns::Apply(
outer_loop_header->AddInstruction(MakeUnique<opt::Instruction>( outer_loop_header->AddInstruction(MakeUnique<opt::Instruction>(
ir_context, SpvOpLoopMerge, 0, 0, ir_context, SpvOpLoopMerge, 0, 0,
opt::Instruction::OperandList{ opt::Instruction::OperandList{
{SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_RESULT_ID, {message_.outer_return_id()}}, {SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_ID, {message_.outer_return_id()}},
{SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_RESULT_ID, {message_.outer_header_id()}}, {SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_ID, {message_.outer_header_id()}},
{SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_LOOP_CONTROL, {SpvLoopControlMaskNone}}})); {SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_LOOP_CONTROL, {SpvLoopControlMaskNone}}}));
// Add conditional branch: // Add conditional branch:
@ -514,8 +515,8 @@ void TransformationMergeFunctionReturns::Apply(
outer_loop_header->AddInstruction(MakeUnique<opt::Instruction>( outer_loop_header->AddInstruction(MakeUnique<opt::Instruction>(
ir_context, SpvOpBranchConditional, 0, 0, ir_context, SpvOpBranchConditional, 0, 0,
opt::Instruction::OperandList{ opt::Instruction::OperandList{
{SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_RESULT_ID, {constant_true}}, {SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_ID, {constant_true}},
{SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_RESULT_ID, {block_after_entry}}, {SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_ID, {block_after_entry}},
{SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_LOOP_CONTROL, {message_.outer_header_id()}}})); {SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_LOOP_CONTROL, {message_.outer_header_id()}}}));
// Insert the header right after the entry block. // Insert the header right after the entry block.
@ -524,7 +525,18 @@ void TransformationMergeFunctionReturns::Apply(
// Update the branching instruction of the entry block. // Update the branching instruction of the entry block.
function->entry()->terminator()->SetInOperands( function->entry()->terminator()->SetInOperands(
{{SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_RESULT_ID, {message_.outer_header_id()}}}); {{SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_ID, {message_.outer_header_id()}}});
// If the entry block is referenced in an OpPhi instruction, the header for
// the new loop should be referenced instead.
ir_context->get_def_use_mgr()->ForEachUse(
function->entry()->id(),
[this](opt::Instruction* use_instruction, uint32_t use_operand_index) {
if (use_instruction->opcode() == SpvOpPhi) {
use_instruction->SetOperand(use_operand_index,
{message_.outer_header_id()});
}
});
// Create the merge block for the loop (and return block for the function). // Create the merge block for the loop (and return block for the function).
auto outer_return_block = auto outer_return_block =
@ -543,9 +555,9 @@ void TransformationMergeFunctionReturns::Apply(
for (auto entry : outer_merge_predecessors) { for (auto entry : outer_merge_predecessors) {
// Each entry is in the form (predecessor, return value). // Each entry is in the form (predecessor, return value).
operand_list.emplace_back( operand_list.emplace_back(
opt::Operand{SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_RESULT_ID, {entry.second}}); opt::Operand{SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_ID, {entry.second}});
operand_list.emplace_back( operand_list.emplace_back(
opt::Operand{SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_RESULT_ID, {entry.first}}); opt::Operand{SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_ID, {entry.first}});
} }
// Insert the OpPhi instruction. // Insert the OpPhi instruction.
@ -559,7 +571,7 @@ void TransformationMergeFunctionReturns::Apply(
outer_return_block->AddInstruction(MakeUnique<opt::Instruction>( outer_return_block->AddInstruction(MakeUnique<opt::Instruction>(
ir_context, SpvOpReturnValue, 0, 0, ir_context, SpvOpReturnValue, 0, 0,
opt::Instruction::OperandList{ opt::Instruction::OperandList{
{SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_RESULT_ID, {message_.return_val_id()}}})); {SPV_OPERAND_TYPE_ID, {message_.return_val_id()}}}));
} else { } else {
// Insert an OpReturn instruction (the function is void). // Insert an OpReturn instruction (the function is void).
outer_return_block->AddInstruction(MakeUnique<opt::Instruction>( outer_return_block->AddInstruction(MakeUnique<opt::Instruction>(
@ -598,7 +610,9 @@ std::unordered_set<uint32_t> TransformationMergeFunctionReturns::GetFreshIds()
protobufs::Transformation TransformationMergeFunctionReturns::ToMessage() protobufs::Transformation TransformationMergeFunctionReturns::ToMessage()
const { const {
return protobufs::Transformation(); protobufs::Transformation result;
*result.mutable_merge_function_returns() = message_;
return result;
} }
std::map<uint32_t, protobufs::ReturnMergingInfo> std::map<uint32_t, protobufs::ReturnMergingInfo>

View File

@ -45,7 +45,7 @@ bool TransformationWrapEarlyTerminatorInFunction::IsApplicable(
return false; return false;
} }
// |message_.early_terminator_instruction| must identify an instruciton, and // |message_.early_terminator_instruction| must identify an instruction, and
// the instruction must indeed be an early terminator. // the instruction must indeed be an early terminator.
auto early_terminator = auto early_terminator =
FindInstruction(message_.early_terminator_instruction(), ir_context); FindInstruction(message_.early_terminator_instruction(), ir_context);

View File

@ -33,12 +33,26 @@ class TransformationWrapEarlyTerminatorInFunction : public Transformation {
const protobufs::InstructionDescriptor& early_terminator_instruction, const protobufs::InstructionDescriptor& early_terminator_instruction,
uint32_t returned_value_id); uint32_t returned_value_id);
// TODO comment // - |message_.fresh_id| must be fresh.
// - |message_.early_terminator_instruction| must identify an early terminator
// instruction, i.e. an instruction with opcode OpKill, OpUnreachable or
// OpTerminateInvocation.
// - A suitable wrapper function for the early terminator must exist, and it
// must be distinct from the function containing
// |message_.early_terminator_instruction|.
// - If the enclosing function has non-void return type then
// |message_.returned_value_instruction| must be the id of an instruction of
// the return type that is available at the point of the early terminator
// instruction.
bool IsApplicable( bool IsApplicable(
opt::IRContext* ir_context, opt::IRContext* ir_context,
const TransformationContext& transformation_context) const override; const TransformationContext& transformation_context) const override;
// TODO comment // An OpFunctionCall instruction to an appropriate wrapper function is
// inserted before |message_.early_terminator_instruction|, and
// |message_.early_terminator_instruction| is replaced with either OpReturn
// or OpReturnValue |message_.returned_value_instruction| depending on whether
// the enclosing function's return type is void.
void Apply(opt::IRContext* ir_context, void Apply(opt::IRContext* ir_context,
TransformationContext* transformation_context) const override; TransformationContext* transformation_context) const override;
@ -46,10 +60,10 @@ class TransformationWrapEarlyTerminatorInFunction : public Transformation {
protobufs::Transformation ToMessage() const override; protobufs::Transformation ToMessage() const override;
private:
static opt::Function* MaybeGetWrapperFunction(opt::IRContext* ir_context, static opt::Function* MaybeGetWrapperFunction(opt::IRContext* ir_context,
SpvOp early_terminator_opcode); SpvOp early_terminator_opcode);
private:
protobufs::TransformationWrapEarlyTerminatorInFunction message_; protobufs::TransformationWrapEarlyTerminatorInFunction message_;
}; };

View File

@ -1650,9 +1650,10 @@ void RunFuzzerAndReplayer(const std::string& shader,
// Every 4th time we run the fuzzer, enable all fuzzer passes. // Every 4th time we run the fuzzer, enable all fuzzer passes.
bool enable_all_passes = (seed % 4) == 0; bool enable_all_passes = (seed % 4) == 0;
auto fuzzer_result = auto fuzzer_result =
Fuzzer(env, kSilentConsumer, binary_in, initial_facts, donor_suppliers, Fuzzer(env, kConsoleMessageConsumer, binary_in, initial_facts,
MakeUnique<PseudoRandomGenerator>(seed), enable_all_passes, donor_suppliers, MakeUnique<PseudoRandomGenerator>(seed),
strategies[strategy_index], true, validator_options) enable_all_passes, strategies[strategy_index], true,
validator_options)
.Run(); .Run();
// Cycle the repeated pass strategy so that we try a different one next time // Cycle the repeated pass strategy so that we try a different one next time

View File

@ -371,6 +371,104 @@ TEST(TransformationComputeDataSynonymFactClosureTest, DataSynonymFacts) {
MakeDataDescriptor(40, {2, 1, 1}), MakeDataDescriptor(108, {2, 1, 1}))); MakeDataDescriptor(40, {2, 1, 1}), MakeDataDescriptor(108, {2, 1, 1})));
} }
TEST(TransformationComputeDataSynonymFactClosureTest,
ComputeClosureWithMissingIds) {
std::string shader = R"(
OpCapability Shader
%1 = OpExtInstImport "GLSL.std.450"
OpMemoryModel Logical GLSL450
OpEntryPoint Fragment %12 "main"
OpExecutionMode %12 OriginUpperLeft
OpSource ESSL 310
%2 = OpTypeVoid
%3 = OpTypeFunction %2
%6 = OpTypeInt 32 1
%7 = OpTypeVector %6 4
%15 = OpConstant %6 24
%16 = OpConstantComposite %7 %15 %15 %15 %15
%17 = OpConstantComposite %7 %15 %15 %15 %15
%18 = OpTypeStruct %7
%19 = OpConstantComposite %18 %16
%30 = OpConstantComposite %18 %17
%12 = OpFunction %2 None %3
%13 = OpLabel
%50 = OpCopyObject %7 %16
%51 = OpCopyObject %7 %17
%20 = OpCopyObject %6 %15
%21 = OpCopyObject %6 %15
%22 = OpCopyObject %6 %15
OpReturn
OpFunctionEnd
)";
const auto env = SPV_ENV_UNIVERSAL_1_3;
const auto consumer = nullptr;
const auto context = BuildModule(env, consumer, shader, kFuzzAssembleOption);
ASSERT_TRUE(IsValid(env, context.get()));
ValidatorOptions validator_options;
TransformationContext transformation_context(
MakeUnique<FactManager>(context.get()), validator_options);
transformation_context.GetFactManager()->AddFactDataSynonym(
MakeDataDescriptor(20, {}), MakeDataDescriptor(15, {}));
transformation_context.GetFactManager()->AddFactDataSynonym(
MakeDataDescriptor(21, {}), MakeDataDescriptor(15, {}));
transformation_context.GetFactManager()->AddFactDataSynonym(
MakeDataDescriptor(22, {}), MakeDataDescriptor(15, {}));
transformation_context.GetFactManager()->AddFactDataSynonym(
MakeDataDescriptor(17, {0}), MakeDataDescriptor(15, {}));
transformation_context.GetFactManager()->AddFactDataSynonym(
MakeDataDescriptor(17, {1}), MakeDataDescriptor(15, {}));
transformation_context.GetFactManager()->AddFactDataSynonym(
MakeDataDescriptor(17, {2}), MakeDataDescriptor(15, {}));
transformation_context.GetFactManager()->AddFactDataSynonym(
MakeDataDescriptor(17, {3}), MakeDataDescriptor(15, {}));
transformation_context.GetFactManager()->AddFactDataSynonym(
MakeDataDescriptor(16, {0}), MakeDataDescriptor(20, {}));
transformation_context.GetFactManager()->AddFactDataSynonym(
MakeDataDescriptor(16, {1}), MakeDataDescriptor(21, {}));
transformation_context.GetFactManager()->AddFactDataSynonym(
MakeDataDescriptor(16, {2}), MakeDataDescriptor(22, {}));
transformation_context.GetFactManager()->AddFactDataSynonym(
MakeDataDescriptor(16, {3}), MakeDataDescriptor(15, {}));
transformation_context.GetFactManager()->AddFactDataSynonym(
MakeDataDescriptor(51, {0}), MakeDataDescriptor(15, {}));
transformation_context.GetFactManager()->AddFactDataSynonym(
MakeDataDescriptor(51, {1}), MakeDataDescriptor(15, {}));
transformation_context.GetFactManager()->AddFactDataSynonym(
MakeDataDescriptor(51, {2}), MakeDataDescriptor(15, {}));
transformation_context.GetFactManager()->AddFactDataSynonym(
MakeDataDescriptor(51, {3}), MakeDataDescriptor(15, {}));
transformation_context.GetFactManager()->AddFactDataSynonym(
MakeDataDescriptor(50, {0}), MakeDataDescriptor(20, {}));
transformation_context.GetFactManager()->AddFactDataSynonym(
MakeDataDescriptor(50, {1}), MakeDataDescriptor(21, {}));
transformation_context.GetFactManager()->AddFactDataSynonym(
MakeDataDescriptor(50, {2}), MakeDataDescriptor(22, {}));
transformation_context.GetFactManager()->AddFactDataSynonym(
MakeDataDescriptor(50, {3}), MakeDataDescriptor(15, {}));
ASSERT_FALSE(transformation_context.GetFactManager()->IsSynonymous(
MakeDataDescriptor(19, {}), MakeDataDescriptor(30, {})));
context->KillDef(20);
context->KillDef(21);
context->KillDef(22);
context->KillDef(50);
context->KillDef(51);
context->InvalidateAnalysesExceptFor(opt::IRContext::kAnalysisNone);
ApplyAndCheckFreshIds(TransformationComputeDataSynonymFactClosure(100),
context.get(), &transformation_context);
ASSERT_FALSE(transformation_context.GetFactManager()->IsSynonymous(
MakeDataDescriptor(19, {}), MakeDataDescriptor(30, {})));
}
} // namespace } // namespace
} // namespace fuzz } // namespace fuzz
} // namespace spvtools } // namespace spvtools

View File

@ -25,7 +25,7 @@ namespace {
protobufs::ReturnMergingInfo MakeReturnMergingInfo( protobufs::ReturnMergingInfo MakeReturnMergingInfo(
uint32_t merge_block_id, uint32_t is_returning_id, uint32_t merge_block_id, uint32_t is_returning_id,
uint32_t maybe_return_val_id, uint32_t maybe_return_val_id,
std::map<uint32_t, uint32_t> opphi_to_suitable_id) { const std::map<uint32_t, uint32_t>& opphi_to_suitable_id) {
protobufs::ReturnMergingInfo result; protobufs::ReturnMergingInfo result;
result.set_merge_block_id(merge_block_id); result.set_merge_block_id(merge_block_id);
result.set_is_returning_id(is_returning_id); result.set_is_returning_id(is_returning_id);
@ -1779,6 +1779,84 @@ TEST(TransformationMergeFunctionReturnsTest, RespectDominanceRules4) {
ASSERT_TRUE(IsEqual(env, after_transformation, context.get())); ASSERT_TRUE(IsEqual(env, after_transformation, context.get()));
} }
TEST(TransformationMergeFunctionReturnsTest, OpPhiAfterFirstBlock) {
std::string shader = R"(
OpCapability Shader
%1 = OpExtInstImport "GLSL.std.450"
OpMemoryModel Logical GLSL450
OpEntryPoint Fragment %2 "main"
OpExecutionMode %2 OriginUpperLeft
OpSource ESSL 310
%3 = OpTypeVoid
%4 = OpTypeFunction %3
%5 = OpTypeBool
%6 = OpConstantTrue %5
%7 = OpConstantFalse %5
%2 = OpFunction %3 None %4
%8 = OpLabel
OpBranch %9
%9 = OpLabel
%10 = OpPhi %5 %6 %8
OpSelectionMerge %11 None
OpBranchConditional %6 %12 %11
%12 = OpLabel
OpReturn
%11 = OpLabel
OpReturn
OpFunctionEnd
)";
const auto env = SPV_ENV_UNIVERSAL_1_5;
const auto consumer = nullptr;
const auto context = BuildModule(env, consumer, shader, kFuzzAssembleOption);
ASSERT_TRUE(IsValid(env, context.get()));
spvtools::ValidatorOptions validator_options;
TransformationContext transformation_context(
MakeUnique<FactManager>(context.get()), validator_options);
auto transformation =
TransformationMergeFunctionReturns(2, 100, 101, 0, 0, {});
ASSERT_TRUE(
transformation.IsApplicable(context.get(), transformation_context));
ApplyAndCheckFreshIds(transformation, context.get(), &transformation_context);
ASSERT_TRUE(IsValid(env, context.get()));
std::string after_transformation = R"(
OpCapability Shader
%1 = OpExtInstImport "GLSL.std.450"
OpMemoryModel Logical GLSL450
OpEntryPoint Fragment %2 "main"
OpExecutionMode %2 OriginUpperLeft
OpSource ESSL 310
%3 = OpTypeVoid
%4 = OpTypeFunction %3
%5 = OpTypeBool
%6 = OpConstantTrue %5
%7 = OpConstantFalse %5
%2 = OpFunction %3 None %4
%8 = OpLabel
OpBranch %100
%100 = OpLabel
OpLoopMerge %101 %100 None
OpBranchConditional %6 %9 %100
%9 = OpLabel
%10 = OpPhi %5 %6 %100
OpSelectionMerge %11 None
OpBranchConditional %6 %12 %11
%12 = OpLabel
OpBranch %101
%11 = OpLabel
OpBranch %101
%101 = OpLabel
OpReturn
OpFunctionEnd
)";
ASSERT_TRUE(IsEqual(env, after_transformation, context.get()));
}
} // namespace } // namespace
} // namespace fuzz } // namespace fuzz
} // namespace spvtools } // namespace spvtools