Add decorations to structs with buffer references

The containsPhysicalStorageBufferOrArray function now handles struct
types correctly, checking their contents recursively for buffer
reference types. As a result, OpVariables containing structs that have
members that are buffer references now have the appropriate
AliasedPointer or RestrictPointer decoration as per the spec.

Fixes #3188
This commit is contained in:
Arcady Goldmints-Orlov 2023-05-18 16:18:42 -06:00 committed by arcady-lunarg
parent d1517d64cf
commit 9caca7a17b
3 changed files with 77 additions and 50 deletions

View File

@ -1373,7 +1373,7 @@ bool Builder::containsType(Id typeId, spv::Op typeOp, unsigned int width) const
} }
// return true if the type is a pointer to PhysicalStorageBufferEXT or an // return true if the type is a pointer to PhysicalStorageBufferEXT or an
// array of such pointers. These require restrict/aliased decorations. // contains such a pointer. These require restrict/aliased decorations.
bool Builder::containsPhysicalStorageBufferOrArray(Id typeId) const bool Builder::containsPhysicalStorageBufferOrArray(Id typeId) const
{ {
const Instruction& instr = *module.getInstruction(typeId); const Instruction& instr = *module.getInstruction(typeId);
@ -1385,6 +1385,12 @@ bool Builder::containsPhysicalStorageBufferOrArray(Id typeId) const
return getTypeStorageClass(typeId) == StorageClassPhysicalStorageBufferEXT; return getTypeStorageClass(typeId) == StorageClassPhysicalStorageBufferEXT;
case OpTypeArray: case OpTypeArray:
return containsPhysicalStorageBufferOrArray(getContainedTypeId(typeId)); return containsPhysicalStorageBufferOrArray(getContainedTypeId(typeId));
case OpTypeStruct:
for (int m = 0; m < instr.getNumOperands(); ++m) {
if (containsPhysicalStorageBufferOrArray(instr.getIdOperand(m)))
return true;
}
return false;
default: default:
return false; return false;
} }

View File

@ -1,7 +1,7 @@
spv.bufferhandle8.frag spv.bufferhandle8.frag
// Module Version 10000 // Module Version 10000
// Generated by (magic number): 8000b // Generated by (magic number): 8000b
// Id's are bound by 27 // Id's are bound by 39
Capability Shader Capability Shader
Capability PhysicalStorageBufferAddressesEXT Capability PhysicalStorageBufferAddressesEXT
@ -21,41 +21,46 @@ spv.bufferhandle8.frag
MemberName 10(T1) 0 "x" MemberName 10(T1) 0 "x"
Name 11 "T2" Name 11 "T2"
MemberName 11(T2) 0 "x" MemberName 11(T2) 0 "x"
Name 13 "T3" Name 13 "x"
MemberName 13(T3) 0 "Bindings" Name 14 "Blah"
Name 15 "t3" MemberName 14(Blah) 0 "t1"
Name 23 "t2" MemberName 14(Blah) 1 "t2"
MemberName 23(t2) 0 "f" Name 16 "T3"
MemberName 23(t2) 1 "g" MemberName 16(T3) 0 "Bindings"
Name 24 "blockType" Name 18 "t3"
MemberName 24(blockType) 0 "a" Name 35 "t2"
MemberName 24(blockType) 1 "b" MemberName 35(t2) 0 "f"
MemberName 24(blockType) 2 "c" MemberName 35(t2) 1 "g"
MemberName 24(blockType) 3 "d" Name 36 "blockType"
MemberName 24(blockType) 4 "e" MemberName 36(blockType) 0 "a"
Name 26 "t" MemberName 36(blockType) 1 "b"
MemberDecorate 8(Blah) 0 Offset 0 MemberName 36(blockType) 2 "c"
MemberDecorate 8(Blah) 1 Offset 8 MemberName 36(blockType) 3 "d"
MemberName 36(blockType) 4 "e"
Name 38 "t"
MemberDecorate 10(T1) 0 Offset 0 MemberDecorate 10(T1) 0 Offset 0
Decorate 10(T1) Block Decorate 10(T1) Block
MemberDecorate 11(T2) 0 Offset 0 MemberDecorate 11(T2) 0 Offset 0
Decorate 11(T2) Block Decorate 11(T2) Block
Decorate 12 ArrayStride 16 MemberDecorate 14(Blah) 0 Offset 0
MemberDecorate 13(T3) 0 Offset 0 MemberDecorate 14(Blah) 1 Offset 8
Decorate 13(T3) Block Decorate 15 ArrayStride 16
Decorate 15(t3) DescriptorSet 0 MemberDecorate 16(T3) 0 Offset 0
Decorate 15(t3) Binding 0 Decorate 16(T3) Block
MemberDecorate 23(t2) 0 Offset 0 Decorate 18(t3) DescriptorSet 0
MemberDecorate 23(t2) 1 Offset 8 Decorate 18(t3) Binding 0
Decorate 23(t2) Block MemberDecorate 35(t2) 0 Offset 0
MemberDecorate 24(blockType) 0 Offset 0 MemberDecorate 35(t2) 1 Offset 8
MemberDecorate 24(blockType) 1 Offset 4 Decorate 35(t2) Block
MemberDecorate 24(blockType) 2 Offset 8 MemberDecorate 36(blockType) 0 Offset 0
MemberDecorate 24(blockType) 3 Offset 12 MemberDecorate 36(blockType) 1 Offset 4
MemberDecorate 24(blockType) 4 Offset 16 MemberDecorate 36(blockType) 2 Offset 8
Decorate 24(blockType) Block MemberDecorate 36(blockType) 3 Offset 12
Decorate 26(t) DescriptorSet 0 MemberDecorate 36(blockType) 4 Offset 16
Decorate 26(t) Binding 0 Decorate 36(blockType) Block
Decorate 38(t) DescriptorSet 0
Decorate 38(t) Binding 0
Decorate 13(x) DecorationAliasedPointerEXT
2: TypeVoid 2: TypeVoid
3: TypeFunction 2 3: TypeFunction 2
TypeForwardPointer 6 PhysicalStorageBufferEXT TypeForwardPointer 6 PhysicalStorageBufferEXT
@ -66,24 +71,38 @@ spv.bufferhandle8.frag
6: TypePointer PhysicalStorageBufferEXT 10(T1) 6: TypePointer PhysicalStorageBufferEXT 10(T1)
11(T2): TypeStruct 9(int) 11(T2): TypeStruct 9(int)
7: TypePointer PhysicalStorageBufferEXT 11(T2) 7: TypePointer PhysicalStorageBufferEXT 11(T2)
12: TypeRuntimeArray 8(Blah) 12: TypePointer Function 8(Blah)
13(T3): TypeStruct 12 14(Blah): TypeStruct 6(ptr) 7(ptr)
14: TypePointer StorageBuffer 13(T3) 15: TypeRuntimeArray 14(Blah)
15(t3): 14(ptr) Variable StorageBuffer 16(T3): TypeStruct 15
16: 9(int) Constant 0 17: TypePointer StorageBuffer 16(T3)
17: 9(int) Constant 1 18(t3): 17(ptr) Variable StorageBuffer
18: TypePointer StorageBuffer 8(Blah) 19: 9(int) Constant 0
TypeForwardPointer 22 PhysicalStorageBufferEXT 20: 9(int) Constant 2
23(t2): TypeStruct 22 22 21: TypePointer StorageBuffer 14(Blah)
24(blockType): TypeStruct 9(int) 9(int) 9(int) 9(int) 9(int) 25: TypePointer Function 6(ptr)
22: TypePointer PhysicalStorageBufferEXT 24(blockType) 28: 9(int) Constant 1
25: TypePointer StorageBuffer 23(t2) 29: TypePointer Function 7(ptr)
26(t): 25(ptr) Variable StorageBuffer TypeForwardPointer 34 PhysicalStorageBufferEXT
35(t2): TypeStruct 34 34
36(blockType): TypeStruct 9(int) 9(int) 9(int) 9(int) 9(int)
34: TypePointer PhysicalStorageBufferEXT 36(blockType)
37: TypePointer StorageBuffer 35(t2)
38(t): 37(ptr) Variable StorageBuffer
4(main): 2 Function None 3 4(main): 2 Function None 3
5: Label 5: Label
19: 18(ptr) AccessChain 15(t3) 16 17 13(x): 12(ptr) Variable Function
20: 8(Blah) Load 19 22: 21(ptr) AccessChain 18(t3) 19 20
21: 18(ptr) AccessChain 15(t3) 16 16 23: 14(Blah) Load 22
Store 21 20 24: 6(ptr) CompositeExtract 23 0
26: 25(ptr) AccessChain 13(x) 19
Store 26 24
27: 7(ptr) CompositeExtract 23 1
30: 29(ptr) AccessChain 13(x) 28
Store 30 27
31: 21(ptr) AccessChain 18(t3) 19 28
32: 14(Blah) Load 31
33: 21(ptr) AccessChain 18(t3) 19 19
Store 33 32
Return Return
FunctionEnd FunctionEnd

View File

@ -27,6 +27,8 @@ layout(set=0, binding=0) buffer T3 {
Blah Bindings[]; Blah Bindings[];
} t3; } t3;
void main() { void main() {
Blah x = t3.Bindings[2];
t3.Bindings[0] = t3.Bindings[1]; t3.Bindings[0] = t3.Bindings[1];
} }