The changes in the existing proto2 code are solely around presence bits. The new generator allocated presence bits more efficiently. (Previously bits were sometimes allocated but never used.)
This is primarily for access to comments, which would be expected to be available in a protoc plugin.
The implementation has two fiddly aspects:
- We use a Lazy<T> to avoid building the map before cross-linking. An alternative would be to crosslink at the end of the constructor, and remove the calls to CrossLink elsewhere. This would be generally better IMO, but deviate from the Java code.
- The casts to IReadOnlyList<DescriptorBase> are unfortunate. They'll always work, because these lists are always ReadOnlyCollection<T> for a descriptor type... but we can't use IList<DescriptorBase> as that's not covariant, and it's annoyingly fiddly to change the field to be of type ReadOnlyCollection<T>.
unittest_proto3 had been changed in a very backward-incompatible
way which was never going to work with C# as it imports proto2 messages.
This is now a copy of the old file, but with a package name change for
compatibility with the remaining files in src/google/protobuf.
The other moves are for files that are only used by C#.
This consists of:
- Changing the codegen for the fixed set of options protos, to parse unknown fields instead of skipping them
- Add a new CustomOptions type in the C# support library
- Expose CustomOptions properties from the immutable proto wrappers in the support library
Only single-value options are currently supported, and fetching options values requires getting the type right
and knowing the field number. Both of these can be addressed at a later time.
Fixes#2143, at least as a first pass.
* Factored Conformance test messages into shared test schema.
* Updated benchmarks to use new proto3 message locations.
* Fixed include path.
* Conformance: fixed include of Python test messages.
* Make maven in Rakefile use --batch-mode.
* Revert changes to benchmarks.
On second thought I think a separate schema for
CPU benchmarking makes sense.
* Try regenerating C# protos for new test protos.
* Removed benchmark messages from test proto.
* Added Jon Skeet's fixes for C#.
* Removed duplicate/old test messages C# file.
* C# fixes for test schema move.
* Fixed C# to use the correct TestAllTypes message.
* Fixes for Objective C test schema move.
* Added missing EXTRA_DIST file.
This is a start to fixing issue #1212. It won't help for test protos,
conformance etc, but it will definitely be better than nothing, and
would have highlighted a change in descriptor.proto which broken C#
earlier.
The conformance tests now use types which are part of src/google/protobuf, so we need to include src in the proto path.
The notes around "fix-ups" have been out of date for some time now.
This introduces a new C# option, base_namespace.
If the option is not specified, the behaviour is as before: no directories are generated.
If the option *is* specified, all C# namespaces must be relative to the base namespace, and the directories are generated relative to that namespace.
Example:
- Any.proto declares csharp_namespace = "Google.Protobuf.WellKnownTypes"
- We build with --csharp_out=Google.Protobuf --csharp_opt=base_namespace=Google.Protobuf
- The Any.cs file is generated in Google.Protobuf/WellKnownTypes (where it currently lives)
We need a change to descriptor.proto before this will all work (it wasn't in the right C# namespace) but that needs the other descriptors to be regenerated too. See next commit...
We now do this in protoc instead of the generation simpler.
Benefits:
- Generation script is simpler
- Detection is simpler as we now only need to care about one filename
- The embedded descriptor knows itself as "google/protobuf/descriptor.proto" avoiding dependency issues
This PR also makes the "invalid dependency" exception clearer in terms of expected and actual dependencies.
This involves:
- Specifying a namespace in each proto (including ones we'd previously missed)
- Updating the generation script
- Changing codegen to implement IReflectedMessage.Fields explicitly (a good thing anyway)
- Changing reflection tests to take account of the explicit interface implementation
Non-generated code in this commit; generated code to follow
Change the C# namespace in descriptor.proto to Google.Protobuf.Reflection.
This then means changing where the generated code lives, which means updating the project file...
It also involves regenerating the C++ - which has updated the well-known types as well,
for no terribly obvious reason...
- Change the default message hash code to 1 to be consistent with other code
- Change the empty list/map hash code to 0 as "empty map" is equivalent to "no map"
- Removed map fields from unittest_proto3.proto
- Created map_unittest_proto3.proto which is like map_unittest.proto but proto3-only
- Fixed factory methods in FieldCodec highlighted by using all field types :)
- Added tests for map serialization:
- Extra fields within entries
- Entries with value then key
- Non-contiguous entries for the same map
- Multiple entries for the same key
Changes to generated code coming in next commit
We still have some protos which aren't generated how we want them to be:
- Until we have an option to specify the "umbrella" class, DescriptorProtoFile
will be broken. (The change of name here affects the reflection descriptor,
which accounts for most of the change. That's easier than trying to work out
exactly which occurrences of Descriptor need changing though.)
- That change affects UnittestCustomOptions
- Issue #307 breaks Unittest.cs
After this commit, we don't have the record of the fixups in the files themselves
any more, but one centralized record in the shell script.
To my surprise, executing generate_protos.sh used the version of Bash installed with Git for Windows by default.
After a few modifications to detect the most appropriate protoc to use, this worked pretty simply.
This change also:
- adds generation of the address book tutorial proto,
- fixes the addressbook.proto to specify proto2 explicitly (to avoid a warning from protoc; I don't think we want warnings...)
- fixes the addressbook.proto C# namespace (which I thought I'd done before, but apparently hadn't)
- includes the regenerated UnittestCustomOptions.cs apart from the DescriptorProtoFIle => Descriptor change
