Commit Graph

2 Commits

Author SHA1 Message Date
Jason McDonald
9b2971cbb4 testlib: Count passes, fails and skips consistently.
For data-driven tests, testlib previously counted one fail or skip for
each data row that failed or skipped, while it counted only one pass
for a test function where all rows passed and counted no passes for a
test function where some rows passed and some rows failed. A similar
problem also existed for benchmark tests, which could run multiple
iterations of the same test, with each fail and skip being counted but
only a single pass being counted for the entire series of iterations.

This commit makes testlib count one pass, fail or skip for each data
row.  Test functions that are not data-driven count one result for the
test function, as before.  Benchmark tests count one pass, fail or skip
per iteration.

A side-effect of this change is that the test output in plain text, xml
and light xml formats now shows a result for every data row and
benchmark iteration executed, allowing post-processors to correctly
calculate the total number of tests executed.  Previously, individual
rows were not shown in the test output if they passed, making such
calculations impossible.

The only change to the xunitxml output format is to correct a bug where
no test result was recorded for a test function if the last data row
was skipped and all other rows passed -- in which case the overall
result should be a pass.  Note that there is also a pre-existing bug
in the xunit logger, where no result is reported if all rows are
skipped; that bug is unaffected by this commit.

Task-number: QTBUG-21848
Task-number: QTBUG-22124
Change-Id: I7e17177e10d6e89e55b9684c159bd506f21d002b
Reviewed-by: Ed Baak <ed.baak@nokia.com>
2012-02-13 01:46:09 +01:00
Jason McDonald
58c617c798 Add testlib selftest for counting of test results.
The test simply generates each possible pair of Pass, Fail and Skip
results.  At present the test simply serves to demonstrate the current
shortcomings of testlib's plain text logging, namely:

* If a test function passes for all data rows, that is counted as one
  pass, but each skipped or failed row counts as one skip or fail.

* Only skipped and failed rows are reported individually in the test
  output. Passed rows are not reported, so it is impossible to see how
  many rows were executed.

* A skip followed by a pass will be reported as an overall pass for the
  test function, but the same rows in reverse order will not report any
  overall result for the test function.

Future commits will attempt to correct these problems.

Task-number: QTBUG-22124
Change-Id: If8c7ea15fc43ba9a1bccd0e881c1efc18e705b25
Reviewed-by: Rohan McGovern <rohan.mcgovern@nokia.com>
2012-02-02 05:42:07 +01:00